The Lord Of The Rings' Army Of The Dead Explained

Aragorn is confronted by the Army of the Dead in The Lord of the Rings

J.R.R. Tolkien's Lord of the Rings trilogy features some pretty strange beings. Orcs are a nocturnal, rough-and-tumble lot. Ents are fascinating arboreal specimens. Wizards are ludicrously powerful geezers. Of all the unique beings that populate Middle-earth, however, the strangest ones might just be the Army of the Dead.

Ghoulish, supernatural, and, to those familiar with Peter Jackson's film adaptations , vibrantly green, the Army of the Dead feels like an abrupt detour from high-fantasy into horror. Inserted into The Return of the King , the specters come flying — quite literally — out of left field, mop up the hosts of Mordor lickety-split, and then vanish as quickly as they appeared, leaving many fans scratching their heads in eerie confusion.

Who are these ghastly creatures and what the heck are they doing floating around the mountains between Rohan and Gondor? Where did they come from? And why is Aragorn able to show up with a shiny reforged sword and start bossing them around? We took a deep dive into the source material to find some answers and ultimately assemble the definitive guide to Tolkien's Army of the Dead.

Setting the stage in the Second Age

In order to understand how the whole "Paths of the Dead" scenario is set up, you have to go way back into the Second Age of Middle-earth history . We're talking about events that take place thousands of years before The Lord of the Rings . During this time, a prosperous nation of men set up their society on a large island called Númenor, out in the ocean to the west of Middle-earth. They are led by a line of kings founded by  Elrond's  brother, Elros. This is the same line of kings that eventually gives us Aragorn .

The Númenóreans are descendants of the first groups of men that migrated into the western lands of Middle-earth thousands of years prior. Once they'd arrived on the scene, they aided the Elves and Dwarves in their struggles, and were given their island nation as a gift from the Valar , the divine shapers and guardians of the world, as a reward for helping to defeat Sauron's old master, Morgoth, at the end of the First Age .

The other men of Middle-earth

While the Númenóreans (or the Dúnedain , as they and their descendants come to be be referred to) are the most important nation of men in Tolkien's stories, they're not the only men of Middle-earth. In fact, there are countless other nations and tribes of men that live all over the continent, including many that live far out in the eastern and southern regions. However, most of these groups are either independent of the larger Lord of the Rings and Silmarillion stories ... or they end up fighting for Sauron. The Silmarillion  explains that thousands of years prior to the main story, "in the south and in the further east Men multiplied; and most of them turned to evil, for Sauron was at work."

Meanwhile, back in Númenor, the Númenóreans become incredibly powerful, and gradually begin to feel a bit cooped up on their isolated island — but they have only one option for expansion. See, when the Valar gave them their new home — as in, literally raised the island up out of the water for them — they put strict limits in place regarding how far these mortal men could sail towards their own immortal land, the Blessed Realm to the west. Having maxed out their potential on Númenor and being restricted from heading west, the Númenóreans start to head east.

The Númenóreans head back to Middle-earth

Time goes on, during which the men of Númenor become increasingly involved in geopolitical events on the continent. Their sixth king, Tar-Aldarion , is particularly instrumental in making them regular visitors to the mainland. Here, they find that the new Dark Lord, Sauron , is beginning to make mischief.

The Silmarillion  says that when they first make contact with the other men on the continent, the Númenóreans "[take] pity on the forsaken world of Middle-earth," adding that "most of the Men of that age that sat under the Shadow were now grown weak and fearful." However, the Númenóreans "[teach] them many things," helping elevate their fearful existence in the process.

In other words, these wise men that show up out of nowhere are hailed as benevolent heroes and teachers. They arrive in fantastic ships, bearing fabulous gifts and tremendous skills. They're basically the Middle-earth equivalent of a Hollywood star who rolls up in a Benz , ready to write checks to whoever needs some help. Over time, though, this perception slowly begins to change.

The Númenóreans get power-hungry

Over the next millennia, the men of Númenor continue to visit Middle-earth from time to time. It's also during this period that Sauron helps the Elves forge the Rings of Power, and then creates the One Ring to rule them all. This leads to an all-out grudge match across the continent as the Elves, Dwarves, and occasionally the Númenóreans try to stop Sauron from conquering everything in sight.

While the Elves and Dwarves often have a rough go of it, every time the Númenóreans show up, it's lights out. As they rack up victories, they set up more and more permanent colonies along the shore, building huge, permanent harbors and towers. In many areas, these are next to local tribes of men who have lived most of their often-difficult lives under the domination of Sauron. The more permanent settling of the Númenóreans may seem like a good thing at first glance, but many men resent this intrusion, and at certain points, even resist the newcomers with violence.

The problem is, while the Númenóreans are technically an improvement (most can agree that anything is better than having Sauron as your neighbor), as they get used to their powerful new position, they slowly shift from being allies to being lords and masters. They demand tribute, and begin to cart off a good amount of the continent's wealth to their increasingly opulent island.

Who are the non-Númenóreans on the mainland?

At this point, the Númenóreans have taken up most of the limelight — which makes a lot of sense. After all, 99% of what Tolkien wrote follows their story, to the varying benefit and detriment of the other men of Middle-earth. In order to get even a basic idea of what these other men are like, one has to do some sleuthing.

First off, these "other" groups of men do make several appearances throughout The Lord of the Rings . The Men of Bree (that is, the town where Frodo and his companions visit the Inn of the Prancing Pony) are among this group. So are the wildmen of Dunland who swear allegiance to Saruman. Then there are the Easterlings that Frodo and Sam see marching into the Black Gates, and, of course, the Haradrim who wreak havoc with their oliphants during the Battle of the Pelennor Fields.

These are just a handful of the different groups of men who live throughout the continent. When the Númenóreans begin colonizing the south of the mainland in the Second Age, there are many others in the area as well, including a group commonly referred to as the Men of the Mountains.

Númenor is destroyed

The Men of the Mountains live in the area that eventually becomes part of Gondor. Before any Númenóreans step foot there, though, these poor souls come under the shadow of Sauron. And we're not just talking about some slight political pressure, or even full-blown conquest. They literally worship the dude. This is during the period of time in the Second Age known as the Dark Years , when Sauron is very nearly in control of all of Middle-earth.

However, Sauron's reign is abruptly ended when a massive army of Númenóreans arrives on the mainland. Playing the long game, the Dark Lord surrenders to them and is taken back to their island nation, where Sauron slowly corrupts the mind of their king. Eventually, the last king of Númenor is convinced to attack the Valar in the Blessed Realm, and his entire kingdom is drowned in an Atlantis-like catastrophe. This makes the Númenórean colonists on the mainland the last remnant of the race, plus a tiny group of survivors who manage to sail away from the sinking island nation during the disaster.

The Faithful set up kingdoms in Middle-earth

The survivors of the wreck of Númenor are part of a faction known as the Faithful . These are men who saw the errant ways of their king and fellow countrymen and decided to remain loyal to the Elves and hostile to Sauron. These "Faithful" survivors of Númenor are led by a man named Elendil and his two sons, Isildur and Anárion.

When they arrive in Middle-earth, they set up two sister kingdoms: Arnor in the north and Gondor in the south — yes, that Gondor. Critically, the Faithful are also good leaders who do not lord it over the local tribes of men or try to take advantage of them — a fact that some of the local tribes fail to notice.

Soon afterward, Sauron arrives back in Middle-earth and begins to make plans to squash what remains of his enemies. As Isildur sets up the kingdom of Gondor, he attempts to find new allies. He converts the nearby Men of the Mountains, convincing them to turn on their fiendish master and help him instead. He brings a great, extraterrestrial-looking black stone, as tall as a man and shaped like a globe, and sets it up on the Hill of Erech near the Men of the Mountains' kingdom. There, he has the King of the Mountains swear allegiance to him.

The Last Alliance

After this somewhat creepy swearing of allegiance, there passes a period of time in which Gondor thrives and the Men of the Mountains enjoy their new, fearless lives. But over time, Sauron gathers his minions, and eventually unleashes hell on the exiles of Númenor. Desperate, the Faithful men of the west turn to their Elven allies, led by a powerful king named Gil-galad, and they form the Last Alliance. This combined army attacks Sauron in Mordor, an event that is shown in the opening sequence of The Fellowship of the Ring . They defeat the Dark Lord's armies and cut the One Ring from his hand.

While this is all great news for the peoples of Middle Earth, there's one group who isn't too pleased to see this come to pass: The Men of the Mountains. See, when Isildur prepares to head out to confront Sauron, he summons the King of the Mountains to fulfill his oath and aid him. What does the mountainous ruler do? He tucks tail and runs.

Cursed by a king

When the King of the Mountains refuses to honor the alliance, Isildur, furious, pronounces a terrible curse. "Thou shalt be the last king," he intones, "and if the West prove mightier than thy Black Master, this curse I lay upon thee and thy folk: To rest never until your oath is fulfilled ... For this war will last through years uncounted, and you shall be summoned once again ere the end."

These ruthless (though totally justified) words terrify the Men of the Mountains, and they flee in terror, caught between an angry Isildur and a petrifying Sauron. They hide in the hills, waiting for the entire thing to just blow over. The thing is, that oath isn't just a frustrated leader blowing smoke. When Isildur cuts the Ring from Sauron's hand and the armies of the Last Alliance return victorious, the curse takes hold, and the Men of the Mountains become known as the Oathbreakers. They slowly die out and become the "Sleepless Dead" that haunt the mountains between Gondor and Rohan.

Haunting the Paths of the Dead

The King of the Mountains' duplicity dooms his people to a life of unsettled specterhood at the end of the Second Age. While Isildur's prophecy that "you shall be summoned once again ere the end," does eventually come true, it takes more than 3,000 years for that day to arrive.

During that interim, the not-quite-dead apparitions of the Men of the Mountains continue to haunt their old homeland, a rugged area between Rohan and Gondor that becomes known as the Paths of the Dead. These paths are referred to multiple times in The Return of the King . At one point, Théoden explains to Merry that "Folk say that Dead Men out of the Dark Years guard the way and will suffer no living man to come to their hidden halls," adding that, "the Dead come seldom forth and only at times of great unquiet and coming death."

Long before the events of The Lord of the Rings , one of the heirs to the throne of Rohan, a fellow named Baldor, attempts to travel on the haunted road. Before he enters, an old, decrepit man blocks the way, declaring that "The way is shut ... It was made by those who are Dead, and the Dead keep it, until the time comes." Ignoring the advice, Baldor foolishly stays on the ghostly path ... and never returns.

The time comes

Centuries of insubstantial half-existence pass, until finally, the day of reckoning for the Oathbreakers arrives. In the book version of The Return of the King , Elrond sends a message to Aragorn: "Bid Aragorn remember the words of the seer, and the Paths of the Dead." Thus the moment, long foretold, comes at last.

This reference to "the seer" denotes yet another ancient prophecy coming to bear upon the situation — it seems they're a dime a dozen with these guys. It was spoken centuries earlier, by a man named Malbeth the Seer. This prophecy, which is enormously long, claims among other things that "The Dead awaken; for the hour is come for the Oathbreakers." It also says that they shall be called to the Stone of Erech by "the heir of him to whom the oath they swore ... he shall pass the Door to the Paths of the Dead." You guessed it: That heir is Aragorn.

Fulfilling their oath: The movie version

At this point, we've caught up to the actual Lord of the Rings narrative, and the story of the Oathbreakers diverges quite a bit depending on whether you're watching or reading the story. In the films, Elrond arrives, gives Aragorn his sword, Andúril, tells him about the fleet of black ships sailed by the Corsairs of Umbar, and encourages him to take the Paths of the Dead to head off the threat.

Aragorn, Legolas , and Gimli head into the mountains alone, summon the Army of the Dead, and arrive in Gondor, where they annihilate their enemies on the black ships. But that's just the beginning of the battle. The Army of the Dead's hugely powerful capabilities are put on full display shortly afterward, when Aragorn pulls up to the docks outside of Minas Tirith and opens up a can of bright green ghosts on the Orcs and men attacking the city. After the unleashed horde mops up the battlefield,  Aragorn informs them — to the dismay of Gimli, who wants to keep them around — that their oath is fulfilled. The Oathbreakers finally fade away, their sins made up for at last.

Fulfilling their oath: The book version

In the book The Return of the King , things go quite a bit differently. After the battle of Helm's Deep, Aragorn, Legolas, and Gimli are joined by 30 of Aragorn's Ranger brethren, as well as Elrond's twin sons. Together, the group travels the Paths of the Dead where they only survive the terror thanks to Aragorn's indomitable willpower.

Once they get through the mountains, Aragorn summons the Army of the Dead to the Stone of Erech, tells them who he is, and orders them to follow him. The ghastly host rides across Gondor to the port town of Pelargir, where they proceed to wipe the floor with the Corsairs of Umbar.

Once they've destroyed Sauron's servants and captured the black fleet, Aragorn releases the entire shadow host right there and then, declaring, "Hear now the words of the Heir of Isildur! Your oath is fulfilled. Go back and trouble not the valleys ever again! Depart and be at rest!" Once the ghosts are gone, the local people gather together, board the ships, and sail off to save Minas Tirith.

A weird connection to Pirates of the Caribbean

The dramatic differences between the Army of the Dead in the books and movies extends to their appearance. In the book, they're referred to as "Shadows" and a "Shadow Host," with Legolas describing them as "shapes of Men and of horses, and pale banners like shreds of cloud, and spears like winter-thickets on a misty night." Gimli reports that they look like "a grey tide," and that he beheld "faint cries ... pale swords ... and dim horns blowing." However, he adds that he doesn't know if they actually could physically hurt anyone, since "the Dead needed no longer any weapon but fear."

So, how, then, did we end up with a glowing green ghost army in Peter Jackson's films? The answer: Pirates of the Caribbean . It turns out that the original Army of the Dead was going to look a bit more skeleton-y. In fact, they were even in the process of creating them that way, when what should come out but The Curse of the Black Pearl , dripping with bony, haggard, undead pirates. The look was so similar, they decided, mid-production, to re-do the Army of the Dead as glowing green ghosts.

Bones or specters, though, it sounds like the production team gave up on a book-accurate "Shadowy Host" right from day one, opting instead for a flashier look. That's Hollywood for you.

The Lord of the Rings: What Exactly Was the Army of the Dead?

The Army of the Dead play a big part in saving Gondor during The Lord of the Rings. But what is this ghostly army, and where did they all come from?

Despite how beloved Peter Jackson's The Lord of the Rings trilogy is, that doesn't mean it's devoid of criticism. One of the most talked about points of contention surrounds the Army of the Dead, featured in The Lord of the Rings: Return of the King . Some book fans disagree with the changes made to their appearance, and some movie audiences get confused about why the army is even there. So, what exactly is the Army of the Dead, and where do they come from?

With Aragorn leading the armies of Rohan through to Gondor, he realizes their forces are too small to make any impactful dent in Sauron's legions . For the movie adaption, he then enters the White Mountains and travels the Paths of the Dead, leading to a vast underground city of decaying green ghosts. After challenging their king, Aragorn commands them to fulfill their oath and fight against Sauron's forces in Gondor, which helps save the day. However, these events only slightly reflect their role in the original novels.

RELATED: Which Race Was the First To Live in Lord of the Rings' Middle-earth?

Within Tolkien's lore, the Army of the Dead date back to the Last Alliance of Elves and Men, when Middle-earth was at war. This conflict spanned hundreds of years, and somewhere along that timeline, there was an unnamed army of men who worshiped the Dark Lord. These men did Sauron's bidding until, at some point, they abandoned him and bowed down to Isildur. The group then swore alliance with Gondor and made an Oath to fight beside Isildur when called for.

However, when the army was called upon during the final days of the war, they refused to fulfill their duty. Be it out of respect for Sauron or fear of his power, they simply stayed put as Isildur called for them. And it was at this moment the King of Gondor placed a curse upon them using the words, "...this curse I lay upon thee and thy folk; to rest never until your oath is fulfilled. For this war will last through years uncounted, and you shall be summoned once again ere the end."

RELATED: How Saruman Fixed the Orcs' Biggest Weaknesses in The Lord of the Rings

With a reluctance to fight Sauron and a fear of Isildur's wrath, the army ran away and hid inside the White Mountains. But then they had to deal with the curse, as none could pass on after death, being bound to their existence inside the mountain for thousands of years. Only an heir of Isildur could free them, and as luck would have it, Aragorn came to call for their aid .

In the novels, Aragorn summoned the Army of the Dead upon the Hill of Erech, located just outside the mountains. And unlike the movies, they traveled around the surrounding area, scarring away many of the nearby raiders and townsfolk. Finally, they reached the city of Pelargir, a harbor overrun by Sauron's forces. And with a swift battle that posed no challenge, the Army of the Dead struck down and pushed out any worshipers of the Dark Lord. With their oath fulfilled, the army was finally able to rest and fade away from the world.

To avoid introducing too many battles and locations, the movie Army of the Dead got added to the Battle of Minas Tirith. Although the army still have the same origin, some fans have disagreed with the adaptation, as it can make them feel like a convenient plot device to end the battle. But at least in the Extended Editions of The Lord of the Rings , they receive far more scenes than the theatrical cut and fit more naturally into the film.

The One Wiki to Rule Them All

Dead Men of Dunharrow

  • View history

The Dead Men of Dunharrow or Men of the Mountains , referred to in adaptations as the Army of the Dead , were Men of the White Mountains cursed to remain in Middle-earth by Isildur , after they abandoned their oath to aid him in the War of the Last Alliance . They haunted the caverns beneath the Dwimorberg , and the valley of Harrowdale that lay in its shadow, though they were said to appear in the valley only in times of trouble or death. They were led by the King of the Dead . Since the line of Isildur was thought in the late Third Age to have ended, no one could call upon the Dead Men of Dunharrow to aid them in their hours of need, as they would only answer to an Heir of Isildur .

Blackroot Vale

The Dead Men following Aragorn, as depicted by Ted Nasmith

History [ ]

They were once Men of the White Mountains, but at the founding of Gondor , they swore an oath to Isildur that they would fight for him. However, during the dark years, they had worshiped Sauron , and so when the time came and Isildur asked for their aid, they refused. And so Isildur cursed them, saying: "Thou shalt be the last king, and if the west prove mightier than thy Black Master, this curse I lay upon thee and thy folk; to rest never until your oath is fulfilled. For this war will last through years uncounted, and you shall be summoned once again ere the end." Therefore, they fled from the wrath of Isildur and dared not go forth to war for Sauron, and they hid in secret places in the mountains and had no dealings with other men. They slowly started to dwindle and the terror of the Sleepless Dead came about to all the places where they lingered. Malbeth the Seer prophesied that a day would come when need and haste would drive one of Isildur's heirs to take the Road under the Mountain , and that the Dead would answer to his call. The Prophecy came true when, in the War of the Ring , Isildur's Heir, Aragorn , called on the Dead Men. Summoning them to the Stone of Erech , Aragorn commanded them to fulfill their oath and be free. [1] Aragorn led the Dead Men through Lamedon . As they went through the lands of Gondor , they found them deserted, since everyone who hadn't gone to war fled the approach of the dreaded King of the Dead . Even the Men of Umbar and Harad , who had been attacking the fords at Linhir above the mouth of the river Gilrain , stopped fighting and ran off in terror. The only person who had the courage to stay was Angbor , the Lord of Lamedon, and Aragorn told him to gather his men and follow the Grey Company to Pelargir . For four days and nights after Aragorn first summoned the dead to the Stone of Erech, they rode. [2]

Army of the Dead, Darrell Sweet

The Dead assailing the fleet that sails toward Minas Tirith , by Darrell Sweet

On the fifth day, they reached Pelargir, where the black fleet of Umbar was assembled. Rumors of the Army of the Dead had already reached the city, but the Corsairs there turned at bay and laughed, seeing only Aragorn and his host of live Dúnedain warriors. Aragorn then called to the Army of the Dead to fight, and they emerged, driving the Corsairs away from their ships. Legolas , after the Battle of the Pelennor Fields , later described the scene he witnessed to Meriadoc Brandybuck and Peregrin Took : "Faint cries I heard, and dim horns blowing, and a murmur as of countless far voices: it was like the echo of some forgotten battle in the Dark Years long ago. Pale swords were drawn; but I know not whether their blades would still bite, for the Dead needed no longer any weapon but fear." Despite not needing weapons, the weapons of the Enemy could not harm them. [2] Once the Haradrim and Corsairs were defeated, Aragorn had trumpets sounded and the Dead withdrew to the shore. As they had at last fulfilled their oath, Aragorn granted the Dead Men their freedom. The King of the Dead stepped forward, broke and discarded his spear; he bowed to Aragorn, and with his people vanished at last from the world. [2]

Inspiration [ ]

Northern European folklore tells of 'the restless dead' as fell riders bursting upon unwary travellers in lonely places. Horses, knights, hounds are among the restless spirits in the "Wild Hunt". Hans Sachs' poem, "Das wütend Heer der kleinen Dieb" (1539) describes the furious host in gruesome detail, accompanied by ravens who plucked out the eyes of the roving dead: "there came one behind, who had been hanged the same day, had still his eyes and saw me."

It is an indication of Aragorn's heroic nature and lineage that he dares summon the dead to fulfill their oath in this manner, and a sign that the rightful king has indeed returned. [ citation needed ]

Portrayal in adaptations [ ]

The lord of the rings film trilogy [ ].

Aragorn and army of dead

Aragorn and the Dead Men rushing towards besieged Minas Tirith

In Peter Jackson 's movie adaptation of The Return of the King , the battle with the Corsairs occurrs off-screen (part of it is shown in the extended edition) and the Army of the Dead accompany Aragorn to Minas Tirith , replacing the Grey Company , to defeat Sauron's Orcs , after which Aragorn declares their curse lifted. Legolas correctly states that it was Isildur who cursed them, but incorrectly states that he was "the last king of Gondor". (Isildur was the last high king of Gondor and Arnor, after which the two kingdoms divided and would both eventually be left kingless until Aragorn took the throne.)

The dead army does not go to the Stone of Erech, but instead, Aragorn confronts them in front of what appears to be their city. The Dead appear as green and glowing, and are more reluctant to fulfill their oath; the King even swings at Aragorn with his sword. While the books make no mention of anything being able to harm the Dead, in the film, the King's own sword is contacted and blocked by Aragorn’s sword Andúril ( Narsil reforged).

Video games [ ]

The return of the king video game [ ].

In The Return of the King video game , the dead army glows a more blue color, and Aragorn, Legolas, and Gimli are all able to harm them. Two levels feature the dead army, one the Paths of the dead where Aragorn and his companions fight their way through the paths of the dead, and the other the King of the dead where Aragorn fights the dead king. After the Dead king is defeated by Aragorn, he and his friends must escape from the paths of the dead. The dead army appears one more time in the game at the end of the Battle of the Pelennor Fields to help save Minas Tirith from Sauron's army . In addition to the Return of the King video game storyline, soldiers of the dead army also appear in the Palantir of Saruman bonus level, in which the player must defeat 20 waves of enemies in an arena; about half of those enemies are dead soldiers.

The Battle for Middle-earth I and II [ ]

Oathbreakers

The icon for summoning the oathbreakers in the BFME games

The Army of the Dead is summonable in all The Battle for Middle-earth games, being the most expensive Power for Gondor and Rohan in the first game. The Army of the Dead fullfilled the role of the superweapon for the force of Man, they can destroy vast armies alone, gliding through any types of units while seemingly sap the life of them at a rapid rate while being nigh-invincible against retaliatory attack. However they lasts for only two minutes and deals little to no damage to buildings. Certain entity of vast magical power such as Sauron, Summoned Dragon or similar can actually hurt them. In The Battle for Middle-earth II , they are only available in Skirmishes and the Evil Campaign, in which the player must move the forces of Evil to destroy all the Dead soldiers and the Fellowship at Rivendell. Apart from being a 25-point faction power, Aragorn , when at level 10, can summon one temporary horde of Oathbreakers.

T he Third Age [ ]

In The Lord of the Rings: The Third Age , the player has the opportunity to summon the Army of the Dead through Aragorn in the later stages of the final Map location, Pelennor Fields . This skill costs 255 AP to use, but with Aragorn's abundant supply of 3000 Max AP, it is definitely worth it. When this power is activated, the Dead mobilize behind Aragorn and charge forth at the enemy. Led by the King of the Dead , the Dead army can do any range of extreme damage from 25000 (Nazgûl) to 50000, and they usually kill any unit apart from Nazgûl and Trolls. This is arguably the best move in the entire game, including Perfect Mode moves.

Conquest [ ]

In The Lord of the Rings: Conquest , Aragorn's special heavy attack is "Wave of Undead", with which he summons several Dead Men to attack an enemy for a very brief time.

See also [ ]

  • Paths of the Dead
  • King of the Dead

Gallery [ ]

Artist drawing of the Army of the Dead

Translations [ ]

References [ ].

  • ↑ The Lord of the Rings , The Return of the King , Book Five, Ch. II: " The Passing of the Grey Company "
  • ↑ 2.0 2.1 2.2 The Lord of the Rings , The Return of the King , Book Five, Ch. IX: " The Last Debate "
  • Lord of the Rings

Screen Rant

Why lord of the rings' dead army are ghosts (did isildur use magic).

The Lord of the Rings: Return of the King features the dead army from the White Mountains, but how they came to be ghosts is somewhat ambiguous.

The Army of the Dead in The Lord of the Rings : Return of the King may have caused some confusion concerning how Isildur's curse was able to turn the Men of the White Mountains into ghosts. Return of the King is the third and final Lord of the Rings movie, though Tolkien's world now has a new series with The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power . Moreover, Warner Bros. has announced its intention to produce a new series of Lord of the Rings movies, which has also reignited many old questions and debates about the franchise and its lore.

The Men of the White Mountains, who are turned into ghosts by Isildur's curse after they refused to fulfill their oaths to fight beside him, are a critical part of the Return of the King ending , and their arrival is what turned the tide in the Battle of the Pelennor Fields. Aragorn, the heir of Isildur, convinces the Army of the Dead to fight for him against Sauron's forces by promising to hold their oath fulfilled if they join him. True to his word, Aragorn releases them following the Battle of the Pelennor Fields, allowing the Men of the White Mountains to have peace at last.

Related: Where to Watch The Lord of The Rings: The Return of The King

Why Lord Of The Rings' Dead Army Became Ghosts

The Lord of the Rings ' Army of the Dead was turned into ghosts because Isildur's curse prevented them from passing on from the mortal world. There is a power to oaths in Lord of the Rings that allowed Isildur's curse to hold, despite the fact that Isildur knew no magic to enhance it with. It's difficult to say with absolute certainty how Isildur's curse was able to keep the Men of the White Mountains trapped in the mortal world, but the examination of other oaths in Tolkien's world, such as the infamous Oath of Feanor, shows how powerful an oath can be.

Furthermore, it is helpful to consider the blurred lines between the mortal and unseen worlds. It would seem that the Ring Wraiths, Sauron, and the Ring Bearer are all, in one way or another, able to exist between the two worlds, at least at times. Considering the blurred connection between worlds and the inherent power of oaths in Tolkien's universe, it would seem that Isildur's curse blocked the Army of the Dead from the unseen world, forcing them to exist in the mortal world where they did not belong. They appear as ghosts because their bodies have decayed, but their souls are trapped by the curse and their oaths.

Related: 10 Best Quotes From The Lord Of The Rings Trilogy, According To Reddit

ROTK's Dead Army Continues Tolkien's Magic Ambiguity

Tolkien is intentionally vague about the nature of magic in his universe, a trend which is continued by the Army of the Dead in Return of the King. He leaves the inner workings of magic purposefully ambiguous. It can be difficult to decipher the limitations or possibilities of any type of magic - however, this is likely meant to maintain a level of awe and mystique.

Moreover, ambiguous definitions of magic's abilities and limitations allow them to be altered when needed. This is why it's not explicitly clear why the Men of the White Mountains became ghosts upon breaking their oaths. Even so, it is enough to know that they broke their oaths and because of it remain trapped between worlds until they fulfill their duty in The Lord of the Rings : Return of the King .

🧙 The Tolkien Forum 🧝

  • Search wiki pages

which lord of the rings has the ghost army

  • Tolkien Wiki
  • Races and Peoples

Army of the Dead

Isildur’s curse, aragorn’s summoning.

The King of the Oathbreakers by Ted Nasmith.

Inspiration

Adaptations, the lord of the rings: the return of the king.

Aragorn and the dead army.

The Return of the King

Army of the Dead in LoTR The Return of the King.

The Lord of the Rings Online

The battle for middle-earth i and ii, the lord of the rings: the third age, the lord of the rings: conquest, card game: lotr.

This page has been seen 73,748 times.

  • Created by esrbl on Jul 7, 2020 Last updated by Aethelwulf on Aug 28, 2023

Share this page

Questions & discussions about army of the dead.

1stvermont

  • Apr 29, 2018
  • "The Lord of the Rings"

CirdanLinweilin

  • Stephen J. Servello
  • Oct 22, 2017
  • "The History of Middle-earth"

Erestor Arcamen

  • Jan 2, 2003

which lord of the rings has the ghost army

General info

Discussions.

  • Started by 1stvermont
  • Replies: 18
  • Started by Stephen J. Servello
  • Started by Calimehtar

Search Wiki

Show results of these types.

  • #!-- XEN:VWPHRASE vw_teamitem ARGS() --#
  • Anonymous page
  • Disambiguation page
  • Special page

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature currently requires accessing the site using the built-in Safari browser.

  • This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register. By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies. Accept Learn more…

IMAGES

  1. [60FPS] Lord of the Rings Ghost Army Scene 60FPS HFR HD

    which lord of the rings has the ghost army

  2. The Lord Of The Rings' Army Of The Dead Explained

    which lord of the rings has the ghost army

  3. Famous Lotr Ghost Army References

    which lord of the rings has the ghost army

  4. The Lord of the Rings: What Was the Army of the Dead?

    which lord of the rings has the ghost army

  5. [60FPS] Lord of the Rings Ghost Army Scene 60FPS HFR HD(1080P_HD)

    which lord of the rings has the ghost army

  6. LOTR Extended Edition // 50

    which lord of the rings has the ghost army

VIDEO

  1. SIEGE OF ORTHANC TOWER

  2. SURVIVE AT ANY COST! 1000 Dwarves VS 9000 Elite Goblins

  3. Rohan VS Isengard

  4. Lord of the Rings

  5. DON'T NEGLECT ROHAN! Great in BOTH Raid Chapters! LotR: Heroes of Middle-earth!

  6. The 8 Fortresses Of Evil